ROSAH Files Lawsuit Challenging Borough of Rumson’s Settlement Agreements with FSHC and Yellow Brook

ROSAH’s counsel filed a Complaint in Lieu of Prerogative Writs in Monmouth County Superior Court today against the Borough of Rumson, Fair Share Housing Center and Yellow Brook Property Co., challenging the settlement agreements reached by the parties in the Borough’s action seeking a declaration of compliance with its affordable housing obligations under New Jersey’s Fair Housing Act and Mount Laurel doctrine.


In the Complaint, ROSAH challenges the adoption of Borough resolutions authorizing the execution of the settlement agreements, and alleges that:


  • The Borough failed to comply with the Open Public Meetings Act during the declaratory judgment litigation, and improperly delegated to a standing committee its authority to negotiate and settle the litigation;


  • The Borough’s adoption of the resolutions was against public policy as the proposed settlements go against the strong preference for municipalities to keep control over their own zoning power, particularly where there is no connection between the proposed settlements and the achievement of any goal under the Fair Housing Act;


  • The settlement agreements were negotiated without any public input, depriving the Borough and its citizens of the ability to consider and discuss new and alternative methods of settlement that would better serve the Borough;


  • The settlement agreements are inconsistent with the requirements of the Fair Housing Act, New Jersey’s COAH regulations and Borough code; and


  • The settlement agreements effectively authorize contract zoning and spot zoning, given that they do not create a realistic opportunity for the creation of affordable housing, and the process that led to the resolutions has violated the both the procedural and substantive due process rights of Rumson’s residents. Download and read the Complaint



Recent Posts

See All

ROSAH receives 501(c)(3) determination from IRS

The Internal Revenue Service has granted ROSAH 501(c)(3) status as a public charity. This is to be applied retroactively to ROSAH's founding in February 12, 2020. Any contributions already made to ROS